Jonathan Stevens Mattress Review

Updated May, 2021
Advertiser Disclosure
Check Price →

Jonathan Stevens is a Michigan-based mattress company that produces name brand quality mattresses for half the price. With over 30 models, 5 collections, and a variety of constructions and firmnesses, Jonathan Stevens caters to a wide variety of sleep preferences and needs, affordably.

Pick Jonathan Stevens if...

  • You're on a budget. Jonathan Stevens strives to produce name brand quality for 50% less of the name brand price, so you can enjoy a good night's sleep without breaking the bank. If you're saving up or on a budget, Jonathan Stevens is a great choice.
  • You want to shop from a wide range of collections, models, and firmnesses. With over 30 models across 5 different mattress collections, Jonathan Stevens provides a comprehensive range of hybrid, innerspring, and all-foam models. You're bound to find the right fit from Jonathan Stevens.
  • You want easy set up and disposal of your old mattress. Jonathan Stevens ships and sets up your mattress in your home, completely free of charge. They'll even remove your old mattress for free for a seamless setup experience.

Seek alternatives to Jonathan Stevens if...

  • You're looking for a top-of-the-line luxury mattress. While Jonathan Stevens provides quality comfort at a great price, they aren't a luxury purchase. If you're looking for a luxury brand that doesn't skimp on comfort or quality, check out Saatva instead.
  • You need a sleep trial. Jonathan Stevens doesn't include sleep trials with their mattresses, which could be a con if you're indecisive, or simply need some time to make sure your new mattress is the right fit. In this case, Saatva is a great alternative. They offer a generous 180-night, risk-free trial.


With five different collections and over 30 models to choose from, Jonathan Stevens provides a comprehensive firmness range to suit all of their customer's preferences.

  • Plush: This firmness level is optimal for side and combination sleepers looking for shoulder and hip pressure relief. If you like superior cushioning and feeling more "in" your mattress than "on" it, plush caters to this preference.
  • Luxury Firm: This is a medium firmness level ideal for all sleep styles, including back and stomach sleepers. Luxury firm provides the cushioning you crave with the support you need for healthy spine alignment.
  • Firm: Firm is best for back and stomach sleepers who still want a mattress that provides adequate give and responsiveness.
  • Extra Firm: Extra Firm models provide superior support and weight distribution, optimal for stomach sleepers. You'll feel more "on" than "in" this mattress.

Construction & Design

  • Jonathan Stevens makes innerspring, hybrid, and all foam models.
  • ComfortRest Mattress Line: This innerspring mattress line is Jonathan Stevens' most basic, using simple quality materials for a great value mattress. The VertiCoil system provides support, while cushioning foam layers make this mattress soft and comfortable as well.
  • ComfortMaster Mattress Line: This mattress line ensures comfort and durability at a mid-range price. Each model equalizes body weight distributions using an advanced coil system, making the ComfortRest line ideal for couples. Each model is also double insulated for extra comfort and longevity.
  • SensuRest Mattress Line: This mattress line offers memory gel foam, latex, and a combination of the two for the best of both worlds. SensuRest Gel models offer cooling technology in combination with their slow-release foam for an ultra-comfortable sleep surface. SensuRest Latex uses natural latex for an ecological option providing supportive, buoyant comfort. SensuRest Fusion models combine the durability of latex with the pressure relieving properties of memory foam for a unique and comfortable sleep experience.
  • Regent Mattress Line: Featuring a heavy-duty orthopedic innerspring system combined with ample foam layering and deep quilting, the Regent line delivers durable, pressure-relieving comfort that's good for your back.
  • Hospitality Mattress Line: This mattress line delivers hotel mattress quality in the comfort of your home. Each model uses a ComfortFlex coil system in unison with a ComfortGuard encased perimeter coil system for advanced, edge-to-edge support.

Motion Isolation

Because of Jonathan Stevens' wide range of models, motion isolation varies from line to line. While the ComfortRest line's basic coil system may not perform the best in this department, the Regent and Hospitality lines perform well. The orthopedic and ComfortFlex coil systems evenly distribute weight, reducing motion transfer for a sounder sleep. These two lines are especially well-suited for couples.

Edge Support

Jonathan Stevens doesn't release all of their mattress specifications online, but it appears that only their Hospitality line has an edge support system, meaning that the rest of their lines don't perform as well. While the Hospitality line's ComfortGuard system maximizes usable surface area and prevents roll-off, other Jonathan Stevens mattresses may not perform as well due to their lack of this system.

Bed Frame Compatibility

Jonathan Stevens is compatible with any frame, as long as the mattress is the correct size for the frame.


Jonathan Stevens ships and sets up your mattress for free, and even disposes of your old mattress for you, free of charge. Returns, however, are not free. Exchanging your mattress before 60 days of ownership costs $199, and after 60 days costs $99. If you want to return your mattress, it'll cost you 20% of the restocking fee, or $200–whichever is greater. All mattresses include a warranty ranging from 5-15 years depending on the model.

Why Buy Jonathan Stevens?

  • You need a new guest bedroom mattress. If you're looking for a new mattress for the guest room, but don't want to spend a ton of money, Jonathan Stevens has a great solution. Their affordable ComfortRest models are made specifically for occasional use, perfect for the guest room!
  • You're looking for an eco-friendly option. Jonathan Stevens' SensuRest Latex options are perfect if you're an eco-conscious buyer looking for a friendlier alternative to memory foam. Natural latex is healthier for the environment, providing you with a healthier sleep too.
  • You're looking for hotel-level comfort in your home. Jonathan Stevens' Hospitality Line provides the same comfort you experience in a high-end hotel, except in the comfort of your own bedroom. This line is a great choice if you like hotel mattresses better than your own!

Why Avoid Jonathan Stevens?

  • You have to pay for returns. If you're not totally sure your new mattress is the right fit, Jonathan Stevens may not be for you. You'll have to pay for any exchanges or returns in the future! If this is a deal-breaker, consider a company like Saatva. Not only do they offer free white glove delivery and setup, a 180-night sleep trial, but they also never charge you for returns!
  • You're indecisive. With over 30 models in 5 different collections, you may find Jonathan Stevens' abundant choices dizzying. If you'd rather shop from a smaller collection a few great models, check out Saatva.

Final Takeaway

Jonathan Stevens is a great choice if you want affordable, quality mattresses. Their mattresses are also surprisingly comfortable. You can get Jonathan Stevens at a great price, today!

Check Price →