Sealy Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm Review

Updated May, 2021
Advertiser Disclosure
Check Price →

The Sealy Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm mattress has been discontinued. If you were set on this Sealy mattress, there's some good news! Sealy's Posturepedic Plus mattress shares many benefits and features that Sealy Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm mattress seekers might enjoy! It's very close in comparison to price, build, and specs. Below is a review of this mattress's replacement, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus, to give you a better insight whether or not this is the right mattress for you!

But, if you're open to other alternatives, we highly recommend Saatva. It's a highly-rated company known for making luxury mattresses with only the finest materials. They offer a variety of different styles and comfort levels, suitable for all sleeper types. Plus, every one of their mattresses are delivered with free white glove delivery!

While Sealy has discontinued their Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm model, their new Posturepedic Plus model is incredibly similar in construction, feel, and price. The Posturepedic Plus comes with Sealy's Response Pro coil system, cooling technologies, and even allergen protection for a comfortable, supportive sleep.

Pick Sealy's Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm replacement, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus, if...

  • You suffer from allergies. If you're allergic to the family cat, or suffer from seasonal pollen, the Sealy Posturepedic is a great choice. It features an AllergenProtect mattress cover, which eliminates allergens like dust mites or pet dander.
  • You need temperature control. The Sealy Posturepedic Plus provides cool-to-the-touch comfort with Chill Technology. Plus, the SealyCool gel foam layer provides added cooling comfort for an optimal sleep temperature.
  • You want zoned support. This model uses reinforced, targeted support in the middle region of the mattress, focusing on supporting the heaviest parts of your body adequately to promote good spinal health and a better sleep overall.

Seek alternatives to Sealy's Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm replacement, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus, if...

  • You prefer the cradling comfort of memory foam. While the Sealy Posturepedic Plus offers exceptional support and comfort, you'll feel more "on" than "in" this mattress. If you prefer a cradling comfort feel, this model isn't for you. A great alternative is the Loom & Leaf by Saatva. It's built with premium memory foam and superior lumbar support for ultimate comfort.
  • You don't need additional comfort features. If features like an AllergenProtect cover or SealyCool Gel don't matter to you, you don't have to get the Premium! Opt for the Sealy Response Essential for comparable comfort at a lower price point.


The Sealy Posturepedic Plus is available in a wide variety of firmnesses suitable for many different sleep needs and styles. This model's firmness levels range from ultra soft to ultra firm.

  • Ultra Soft: This firmness level is optimal for side and combination sleepers looking for shoulder and hip pressure relief. If you like superior cushioning and feeling more "in" your mattress than "on" it, Ultra Soft caters to this preference.
  • Soft: Slightly firmer than Ultra Soft, this firmness level gives slightly more support while still remaining ideal for side only or combination sleepers.
  • Medium: This firmness level is ideal for all sleep styles, including back and stomach sleepers. Medium provides the cushioning you crave with the support you need for healthy spine alignment.
  • Firm: The second firmest option, Firm is best for back and stomach sleepers who still want a mattress that provides adequate give and responsiveness
  • Ultra Firm: The firmest option, Ultra Firm provides superior support and weight distribution, optimal for stomach sleepers. You'll feel more "on" than "in" this mattress.

Construction & Design

  • The Sealy Posturepedic Plus ranges between 13" and 15" tall, depending on which firmness level you prefer.
  • Chill Technology with AllergenProtect Cover: Chill technology creates a cool-to-the-touch surface sensation, while the AllergenProtect technology fights pesky allergens like pollen, dander, and dust mites.
  • ComfortSense HD Premium Memory Foam: This memory foam layer cradles your body and conforms to your shape to provide custom support.
  • SealyCool Gel Foam: This gel memory foam layer provides targeted support for the heaviest parts of your body while controlling your body's temperature for a cooler and more comfortable sleep.
  • Response Pro Coil System: The Pro Coil System features individually wrapped coils that provide zoned support to your lumbar region, while greatly reducing motion transfer.
  • Duraflex Coil Edge System: This high-density, flexible coil border provides edge-to-edge support to increase usable mattress space and prevent roll-off or sagging.

Motion Isolation

Due to the Sealy Posturepedic Plus's superior coil system, this mattress is great at motion isolation. The Response Pro Coil System target your heaviest areas while leaving the rest of the mattress undisturbed, reducing motion transfer across the bed. This makes the Sealy Posturepedic Plus a great choice for couples, or if your suffer from tossing and turning.

Edge Support

Just like motion isolation, this mattress performs well at providing edge support. Its Duraflex coil edge system uses high density coils around the border of the mattress to increase edge to edge support and usable surface area. The Duraflex system also prevents sagging, so your bed keeps its shape for years to come.

Bed Frame Compatibility

The Sealy Posturepedic Plus is compatible with box springs, slats, or platform foundations, as well as adjustable frames. Avoid putting this mattress directly on the floor, as this setup negates the bed's benefits and speeds up the wear-and-tear process.


All Sealy mattresses ship free to your door inside the US, and usually arrive between 5-7 days. Sealy offers a 100-night sleep trial, so you can return your mattress risk-free within this period. The Sealy Posturepedic Plus is protected by a 10-year warranty.

Why Buy Sealy's Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm replacement, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus?

  1. It's very similar to the Sealy Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm. While this model isn't identical, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus delivers similar comfort and support using a comparable coil and edge system. Innerspring comfort never felt better!
  2. You sleep with a partner. The combined memory foam layers, Response Pro coil system, and Duraflex edge system are all a couple needs to sleep undisturbed comfortably. No more rolling off, sudden waking, or uncomfortable positions!
  3. You're looking for a budget-friendly sleep solution. The Sealy Posturepedic Plus delivers top-tier sleep technology, like CertiPUR-US certified foams, cooling technology, and a robust coil and edge support system for much less than competing brands. If you're looking for quality without a hefty pricetag, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus is a great choice.

Why Avoid Sealy's Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm replacement, the Sealy Posturepedic Plus?

  1. You're looking for the comfort of memory foam. While the Sealy Posturepedic Plus uses memory foam layers, don't be fooled – this innerspring mattress doesn't deliver that classic "sink in" feeling that traditional memory foam mattresses are famous for. Instead, opt for Saatva's Loom & Leaf model, which delivers that memory foam feel you crave.
  2. You're looking for an eco-friendly alternative. These days, there's hundreds of eco-friendly mattresses available, made from all-natural materials. While the Sealy Response Premium is CertiPUR-US certified, it's not an environmentally friendly purchase. In this case, you may want to opt for the Zenhaven by Saatva. It's made with 100% natural Talalay Latex, which is not only healthier for you, it's a sustainable material great for the planet!

Final Takeaway

The Sealy Posturepedic Plus is a great alternative to Sealy's Response Premium West Salem Cushion Firm Replacement if you want comparable comfort and price. This mattress is also surprisingly comfortable. You can get the Sealy Posturepedic Plus for a great price, today!

Check Price →