Wellsville Mattress Review

Updated 3 days ago
Advertiser Disclosure

The Bottom Line

Wellsville creates premium luxury mattresses from CertiPUR-US certified materials to improve your relationship with sleep. Each mattress is crafted from premium materials like gel-infused memory foam, phase change material, latex, and a lower-coil gauge. Wellsville provides a range of different constructions and heights to fit any sleep preference.

While this is a fantastic mattress at this price point, our #1 pick for 2023 is SAATVA mattress. Saatva is a luxury mattress shipped to your door (unlike other bed in a box brands dropped off on your doorstep) w/ FREE white-glove delivery & setup. They have over 50,000 5-star reviews, and they're incredibly comfortable (for all sleep positions).

Check Price →

Check Price →

Pick Wellsville if...

  • You're looking for a natural alternative to memory foam. Wellsville creates a natural latex hybrid model that provides eco-friendly comfort and support. If you're an eco-conscious buyer, or simply want an alternative to memory foam, Wellsville is a great choice.
  • You want to shop from a wide range of models and constructions. Wellsville's four different models are available in differing heights, firmnesses, and features to cater to a wide range of sleep preferences.
  • You want to sleep cool. Wellsville's CarbonCool model features OmniPhase technology, which delivers 20X the cooling power than regular gel memory foam. If you need temperature control, Wellsville is a great pick.

Seek alternatives to Wellsville if...

  • You're on a budget. While Wellsville offers a variety of models, the construction, quality, and technology of these models come with a bigger price tag. If you're trying to save money on your new mattress, Wellsville may not be the right choice for you.
  • You want a classic innerspring. Wellsville only makes foam and hybrid models. If you're looking for that traditional innerspring feel, Wellsville simply isn't for you. In this case, a great alternative is the Saatva Classic. It's a luxury hybrid innerspring mattress that provides you with the support and lift you can only get with a coil base.


With four different models and a variety of different heights to choose from, Wellsville provides a comprehensive firmness range to suit all of their customer's preferences.

  • Plush: This firmness level is optimal for side and combination sleepers looking for shoulder and hip pressure relief. If you like superior cushioning and feeling more "in" your mattress than "on" it, plush caters to this preference.
  • Medium Firm: This is a medium firmness level ideal for all sleep styles, including back and stomach sleepers. Medium firm provides the cushioning you crave with the support you need for healthy spine alignment.
  • Firm: Firm is best for back and stomach sleepers who still want a mattress that provides adequate give and responsiveness.
  • Extra Firm: Extra Firm models provide superior support and weight distribution, optimal for stomach sleepers. You'll feel more "on" than "in" this mattress.

Construction & Design

  • Wellsville mattresses range from 8" to 14" tall.
  • Wellsville provides both all foam and hybrid models.
  • Gel-Infused Memory Foam: This all-foam model features four memory foam layers providing pressure relief, temperature control, and optimal support. The high-density base layer ensures durability and edge-to-edge stability.
  • Gel Memory Foam Hybrid: This model features ventilated, gel bead infused memory foam for plush comfort and cooling. Specialized transition foam evenly distributes support throughout top foam layers from the motion-isolating coil system.
  • Natural Latex Hybrid: This hybrid provides the plush yet springy comfort of natural latex. Individually encased coils absorb and isolate motion, making this model ideal for couples.
  • CarbonCool: This model features OmniPhase technology, which is a phase-changing material which adapts to temperature changes and adjusts accordingly. OmniPhase keeps you 20X cooler than regular gel memory foam, making this model ideal for those who need extra temperature control.

Motion Isolation

All of Wellsville's models provide great motion isolation, but their hybrid models perform exceptionally well in this department. Wellsville's individually wrapped coil systems are designed to absorb movement and eliminate motion transfer for a sounder sleep. Their hybrid models are especially well-suited to couples and those who toss and turn in their sleep.

Edge Support

While each Wellsville mattress features a high density foam base which ensures durability and helps with edge-to-edge support, these mattresses don't have an edge support system like competing mattress brands. The foam base gives these mattresses decent edge support, but it's no match for other brands who use a Dual Perimeter edge support system, like Saatva.

Bed Frame Compatibility

Wellsville mattresses are designed for adjustable bed bases, so adjustable frames are their ideal match. You can technically pair your Wellsville mattress with any frame or foundation, but an adjustable frame works best with these mattresses.


Wellsville doesn't have an online store, so shipping and return policies are entirely up to online or in-store third party retailers. Every Wellsville mattress includes a 1year warranty.

Why Buy Wellsville?

  • You like memory foam but don't want to get too hot. If you enjoy the cradling feel of memory foam, but don't like how hot it can be, then Wellsville is a great choice. Their foam models feature ventilated top layers to keep things cool while delivering the comfort you love.
  • You want a mattress that's easy to clean. Nearly all of Wellsville's models feature a zip-off mattress cover, making it easy to wash any spills or stains from your mattress. This is a great feature if you like snacking in bed, or you have kids/pets.
  • You don't like the bed-in-a-box idea. Wellsville's mattresses are all about delivering you a luxury experience, which means that whether you're buying in-store or online from a third-party retailer, you'll never receive your Wellsville mattress in a box.

Why Avoid Wellsville?

  • You don't have/want an adjustable bed base. If you don't own an adjustable bed base, or you don't want to invest in one, Wellsville may not be the right choice. Each Wellsville mattress is designed to be compatible with adjustable frames, and Wellsville highly suggests this pairing.
  • You want to buy online, directly from the retailer. Wellsville has no online store, so purchasing this mattress isn't as easy as hitting the "checkout" button. If buying through a third-party retailer is a hassle for you, Wellsville isn't for you. In this case, we recommend Saatva. Not only can you purchase directly from their website, all of their mattresses come with their free white glove delivery. Saatva's concierge team delivers and setups your mattress.

Final Takeaway

Wellsville is a great choice if you want luxury quality and comfort. Their mattresses are also surprisingly comfortable. You can get Wellsville at a great price, today!

While this is a fantastic mattress at this price point, our #1 pick for 2023 is SAATVA mattress. Saatva is a luxury mattress shipped to your door (unlike other bed in a box brands dropped off on your doorstep) w/ FREE white-glove delivery & setup. They have over 50,000 5-star reviews, and they're incredibly comfortable (for all sleep positions).

Check Price →

Check Price →
BIGGEST Holiday Sale - Get Up To $600 Off